5 Star Coconut Pie
An old family recipe. Requires baked pie shell, eggs, milk, and vanilla. If topping with meringue, you'll also need egg whites and sugar. |
$4.25
|
Apple/Peach Crisp
This traditional sweet dessert begs to be served underneath a huge scoop of vanilla ice cream. It's packed with walnuts and coconut and is great comfort food. Requires margarine or butter and canned apples or peaches. Makes one 9x9 pan. |
$4.50
Not available - contact us for order details.
|
Aunt Sherry's Pie Crust
A little pricey for "just a pie crust", but it's the best I've tasted. Another thing: it's like a miracle how it comes together. You melt butter in a pie plate, pour in the mix, mix it up with a fork, and press it into the pan. My hat is off to Aunt Sherry, wherever she is. |
$4.25
|
Caramel Pecan Pie
Well shoot. I tried to make this, got distracted, and left out the butter entirely. It looked pretty though! Maybe you'll have better luck. I've heard it's delicious. Requires margarine or butter, eggs, milk, vanilla extract, and an unbaked pie shell. |
$4.75
|
Cheesecake
This is the real thing. Requires cream cheese, eggs, sour cream, and vanilla.
|
$5.00
Not available - contact us for order details. |
Dreamsicle Pie
You remember those orange popsicles with the ice cream in the middle from when you were a kid? Of course you do. It seems like everybody's got a dreamsicle-flavored something or other these days. Creamy, light, and refreshing. Requires cream cheese, whipped cream, and a graham cracker crust. |
$3.75
Not available - contact us for order details. |
Fudge Pie
This recipe was donated by a customer in New Orleans, and the owner of The Gourmet Cupboard said that it was love at first bite. Requires eggs, vanilla, evaporated milk, and margarine or butter.
|
$4.25
|
Funnel Cakes
Tastes exactly like the ones you'll find at festivals and fairs. Requires an egg, milk, oil, and a funnel. Yields 6 cakes. |
$3.75
Not available - contact us for order details. |
Grandma's Pound Cake
I love pound cake for its myriad of uses. My favorite way to eat it is with strawberries and whipped cream. Or drizzled with chocolate fudge. Requires eggs, butter, and sour cream. |
$4.75
Not available - contact us for order details. |
Grandma's Pumpkin Pie/Cheesecake
This recipe belongs to Mama Joy (the owner of The Gourmet Cupboard's grandma), and it has just the kind of old-fashioned flavor that I love. Requires eggs, pumpkin, evaporated milk, vanilla, and an unbaked pie shell. |
$3.75
Not available - contact us for order details.
|
Heavenly Chocolate Pie/Cheesecake
I made the cheesecake version of this a couple of weeks ago for a poker night, and it was OUTSTANDING. I do not hesitate to call it my favorite pie ever. Requires milk, eggs, butter, vanilla, and a pie crust. |
$4.25
|
Key Lime Pie
I was surprised when I looked at the package because the mix in the bag looks just the teeniest bit blue! This is one of The Gourmet Cupboard's best sellers. Requires cream cheese, whipped cream, and a graham cracker crust.
|
$3.75
|
Lemonade Pie
Refreshing and hits the spot, just like a cold glass of lemonade. Requires cream cheese, whipped cream, and a graham cracker crust. |
$3.75
|
Mama Joy's Fruit Cobbler
Mama Joy is at it again. Great with any canned fruit. Requires margarine or butter and (of course) canned fruit. Makes one 7x11 dish. (Note: where does one find a 7x11 dish? 9x9 will have to do for me.)
|
$4.50
Not available - contact us for order details. |
Peanut Butter Pie
Okay, so maybe the heavenly chocolate cheesecake has a match, in my opinion. Peanut butter pie is the ultimate. Requires cream cheese, vanilla, whipped cream, and chocolate cookie crust. |
$3.75
|
Spiced Apple Cake Mix
If you're selling your house, make this cake while prospective buyers are walking through. I guarantee it will make it feel like home. Dark, moist, and flavorful. Requires oil, eggs, and chopped apples. Makes one bundt cake or 9x13 pan. |
$5.75
|
